Pros and cons of tracking your lost items using Apple AirTag versus Tile trackers

If you often lose things, having a tracker can be very helpful. Both Apple’s Find My Network with the AirTag and Amazon Sidewalk with the Tile tracker have fantastic features that can help you locate your lost items every time.

However, both have their pros and cons. Let’s see what Find My and Sidewalk can do and whether the Air Tag or the Tile device suits you better.

What is Apple’s Find My Network? 

Apple’s Find My Network is a crowdsourced network of hundreds of millions of Apple devices that use Bluetooth wireless technology to detect missing devices or items nearby and report their approximate location back to the owner.  It’s completely free to use and can help you to keep track of your Apple devices 24/7, even if they are offline or have low batteries.

However, it requires that you have an Apple ID and enable Find My on your device. The Find My network is also compatible with AirTags and Find My network accessories. The Find My Network accessories are third-party products that use Find My technology to locate lost items.

The Find My network is designed to be end-to-end encrypted and anonymous, so no one else, not even Apple or the third-party manufacturer, can view it. device’s location or information. Only the person seeking the lost device can see the item’s location.

What is the Amazon Sidewalk network used by Tile trackers? 

Amazon Sidewalk is a shared network that helps devices like Amazon Echo devices, Ring Security Cameras, outdoor lights, motion sensors, and Tile trackers work better at home and beyond the front door. When enabled, Amazon Sidewalk can unlock unique benefits for your device, support other Sidewalk devices in your community, and even locate pets or lost items.

Amazon Sidewalk is free to use and is designed to be end-to-end encrypted and anonymous, so no one else, not even Amazon or the third-party manufacturer, can view a device’s location or information. Amazon Sidewalk requires that you have an Amazon account and enable Sidewalk on your device.

For the best AirTag and Tile tracker options, go to CyberGuy.com/BluetoothTrackers

Should I use the Air Tag with Find My or the Tile with Sidewalk? 

This is a tough question to answer because both devices have their advantages and disadvantages, and it really depends on what exactly you’re looking for in a tracker. Let’s go over the pros and cons of each device so that you can see everything laid out for you to help you make a decision choosing between both options.

Device compatibility 

AirTag (Apple Only) 

• Pros: Compatible with iPhones, iPads, and iPod Touches that run with iOS 14.5 or iPad OS 14.5 or later, including the iPhone 6S or later and iPhone SE 1, 2, and 3. It is also compatible with Macs running macOS Catalina 10.15.5 or later and Apple Watches running watchOS 6 or later.
• Cons: Only compatible with Apple devices. In order to track an AirTag, you must be running iOS 14.5 or above on your iPhone or iPadOS 14.5 on your tablet.

Tile (Apple and Android) 

• Pros: Compatible with both iOS and Android devices through the free Tile app. Works with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri.
• Pros: The Tile slim is designed to be ultra-thin and shaped like a credit card so that it can easily fit into a wallet. On the other hand, the Apple AirTag is a bit bulkier and requires a keychain or a separate holder.
• Cons: Requires an Amazon account and an Amazon Echo device with Alexa to connect to Amazon Sidewalk.

Privacy settings 

AirTag 

• Pros: Fully encrypts location data end-to-end, which means only the tracker’s owner can see an item’s location. Allows you to enable location access on your device.
• Cons: Concerns about the potential for unwanted tracking or stalking using the AirTag. However, Apple has implemented some features to address these concerns, such as end-to-end encryption of location data and alerts to iPhone users if someone has planted an AirTag on them.

Tile  

• Pros: Allows you to enable location access on your device. Protects location data. Tile’s parent company Life360 promises that it does not sell your data and that your location information is anonymous.
• Cons: The Sidewalk network routes data from compatible devices through not only your Echo and Ring products but also your home WiFi network, and it uses a sliver of your internet bandwidth to do it. This means that when you use the Sidewalk network, you’re not just providing internet access for your own compatible devices but also for anyone’s Sidewalk-enabled devices that are near your house and in range of your Ring cameras or Echo speakers. Some people may have concerns about sharing their internet access with others, as well as potential privacy concerns.

Battery life 

AirTag 

• Pros: Integrated battery that can be replaced.  The Find My app can notify the user when the battery needs replacing.
• Cons: Batteries typically only last up to 1 year before needing to be replaced.

Tile  

• Pros: Several products with different battery life options. Tile Pro has a user-replaceable battery that lasts for a year. Other Tile products have permanent batteries that last for three years.
• Cons: After three years, you’ll need to replace the trackers.

Tracking 

AirTag 

• Pros: Operates through Apple’s Find My network, which utilizes the hundreds of millions of other Apple devices around the globe to provide near-perfect tracking of your stuff. The massive size and truly global reach of the Find My network.
• Cons: No way to ping a phone from the tag.

Tile 

• Pros:  You can use compatible Echo devices to access in-home features such as live location status and speaker detection for your Tiled items. By connecting your Echo devices to Sidewalk and enabling Community Finding, you can help other Tile users find their lost items and increase your chances of finding your own lost items.
• Cons: The size and reach of the Find My network utterly dwarfs Tile, even with its integration with Amazon Sidewalk.  Tile has a network made up of millions of devices, while Apple uses its far-reaching Find My network, approaching a billion devices.